Call us Today!
(847) 212-4951
Thinking about ditching the tub for a sleek walk-in shower? Before you start, there’s one number every Chicago homeowner should know — and it might surprise you. Here’s everything you need to plan your 2026 bathroom upgrade the right way.
Thinking about ditching the tub for a sleek walk-in shower? Before you start, there’s one number every Chicago homeowner should know — and it might surprise you. Here’s everything you need to plan your 2026 bathroom upgrade the right way.
Thinking about ditching the tub for a sleek walk-in shower? Before you start, there’s one number every Chicago homeowner should know — and it might surprise you. Here’s everything you need to plan your 2026 bathroom upgrade the right way.
Thinking about ditching the tub for a sleek walk-in shower? Before you start, there’s one number every Chicago homeowner should know — and it might surprise you. Here’s everything you need to plan your 2026 bathroom upgrade the right way.
Thinking about ditching the tub for a sleek walk-in shower? Before you start, there’s one number every Chicago homeowner should know — and it might surprise you. Here’s everything you need to plan your 2026 bathroom upgrade the right way.
When it comes to upgrading your bathroom, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is choosing between a tub-to-shower conversion and a full bathroom remodel. While both options can improve your space, they differ significantly in cost, scope, timeline, and overall impact.
A tub-to-shower conversion focuses on replacing an outdated bathtub with a modern, functional shower—often without changing the rest of the bathroom. On the other hand, a full remodel involves transforming the entire space, from flooring and fixtures to layout and design.
With bathroom renovations ranking among the top home improvement projects for return on investment and buyer appeal, making the right choice is critical. In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences, real costs, ROI, and practical considerations so you can confidently decide which option fits your needs, budget, and long-term goals.
At its core, the difference between a tub-to-shower conversion and a full bathroom remodel comes down to scope. A conversion is a targeted upgrade that replaces your existing bathtub with a walk-in shower, typically using the same plumbing layout. This makes it a faster and more cost-effective solution for homeowners who want to modernize their bathroom without a full renovation.
In contrast, a full bathroom remodel is a comprehensive transformation. It often includes replacing the vanity, flooring, lighting, fixtures, and sometimes even reconfiguring the layout. Because it involves multiple trades—plumbing, electrical, tiling, and carpentry—it is significantly more complex and expensive.
This distinction is important because it directly affects your budget, timeline, and overall return on investment.
Cost is often the deciding factor for most homeowners, and the difference between these two options is substantial.
A tub-to-shower conversion typically costs between $9,000 and $15,000, with an average around $12,000, depending on materials and labor .More customized projects with high-end finishes can reach $20,000 – $30,000, especially when additional upgrades are included (This Old House).
On the other hand, a full bathroom remodel is a much larger investment. Mid-range remodels generally cost between $15,000 and $30,000, while upscale renovations can exceed $40,000 or more (Modernize).
This means a full remodel can cost two to four times more than a conversion. The higher price reflects the broader scope of work, including materials, labor, and potential structural changes.
Both options can increase your home’s value, but they do so in different ways.
A tub-to-shower conversion typically delivers an ROI of around 60% to 75%, making it one of the most cost-effective bathroom upgrades (HanoDecor). Because it focuses on improving functionality and modernizing a key feature, it offers strong returns relative to its lower cost.
Full bathroom remodels also provide solid returns, usually ranging from 55% to 75% ROI, depending on the project scope and finishes (Modernize). However, while remodels may add more total value to your home, they often have a slightly lower percentage return—especially at the luxury level.
In simple terms, conversions are more efficient investments, while remodels offer greater overall transformation and value increase.
Another major difference between these two options is how long they take to complete.
Tub-to-shower conversions are relatively quick and straightforward. In many cases, they can be completed in just a few days, with some basic installations finished even faster. However, it’s worth noting that 37% of homeowners report their renovation costs exceeded expectations, and disruptions such as temporary bathroom loss are common during the process (This Old House).
In contrast, a full bathroom remodel can take anywhere from 3 to 5 weeks or longer, depending on the complexity of the project. Because remodels involve multiple phases—demolition, plumbing, electrical work, tiling, and finishing—they require careful planning and coordination.
If speed and minimal disruption are priorities, a conversion is the clear winner.
Your lifestyle plays a significant role in determining which option is right for you.
For many homeowners, especially those who rarely use their bathtub, a conversion makes practical sense. Walk-in showers are easier to access, require less maintenance, and align with modern design trends. In fact, industry reports show that over 25% of bathroom renovations now involve removing bathtubs to expand showers, reflecting a shift in how people use their spaces (Better Homes & Gardens).
However, removing the only bathtub in your home can impact resale value, particularly for families with young children. Experts generally recommend keeping at least one tub in the house for flexibility and broader buyer appeal.
A full remodel, on the other hand, is ideal if your bathroom has multiple issues—such as outdated fixtures, poor layout, or lack of storage. It allows you to address everything at once and create a cohesive, modern space tailored to your needs.
Choosing between a tub-to-shower conversion and a full bathroom remodel ultimately depends on your goals.
If your bathroom is in good condition and you’re primarily looking to improve functionality, accessibility, or aesthetics, a conversion is often the smarter choice. It delivers a noticeable upgrade at a fraction of the cost and time.
However, if your bathroom feels outdated, inefficient, or no longer meets your needs, a full remodel may be worth the investment. While it requires a larger budget and longer timeline, it offers a complete transformation and greater long-term impact.
The key is to align your decision with your budget, lifestyle, and future plans—whether that’s improving daily comfort or increasing resale value.
Both tub-to-shower conversions and full bathroom remodels offer significant benefits, but they serve different purposes. A conversion is a fast, cost-effective way to modernize your bathroom and improve functionality, while a full remodel provides a comprehensive upgrade that transforms the entire space.
With conversions costing a fraction of a full remodel and offering strong ROI, they are often the best choice for homeowners seeking efficiency and practicality. However, for those looking to completely redesign their bathroom and maximize long-term value, a full remodel may be the better investment.
Ultimately, the right choice comes down to your specific needs, budget, and vision. By understanding the differences in cost, ROI, and scope, you can confidently choose the option that delivers the best results for your home.
If you are considering a custom bathroom remodel, the first step is a professional evaluation of your existing space.